| Father | Male Eli McCarter |
| Born | Feb 1838 | Gatlinburg, Sevier County, Tennessee  |
| Died | 1916 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Buried | P. A. Proffitt Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Married | 21 Mar 1861 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Father | Joseph Benjamin McCarter | F492 Group Sheet | |
| Mother | Nancy Reagan | F492 Group Sheet | |
| Mother | Female Dicy Ownby |
| Born | Aug 1842 | Gatlinburg, Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 1921 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Buried | P. A. Proffitt Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Father | Nicholas H. Ownby | F733 Group Sheet | |
| Mother | Mary Ogle | F733 Group Sheet | |
| Child 2 | Female > Nancy McCarter |
| Born | 20 Dec 1861 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 30 Dec 1940 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Buried | 1 Jan 1941 | Walden's Creek Methodist Church Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Spouse | Isaac Bradley Huskey | F534 | |
| Married | 19 Oct 1876 | |
| Child 3 | Female > Deborah A. McCarter |
| Born | 1866 | , Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 1897 | |
| Buried | Forks of the River Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Spouse | Louis A. Reagan | F282 | |
| Married | 24 Apr 1887 | |
| Child 4 | Male > Perry Earl McCarter |
| Born | 11 Feb 1869 | , Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 11 Dec 1959 | |
| Buried | Modesto, Stanislaus, California |
|
| Spouse | Rhoda Malinda Reagan | F542 | |
| Married | 26 Sep 1886 | |
| Child 5 | Male > Pinkney McCarter |
| Born | 1872 | , Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 1899 | |
| Buried | ||
| Spouse | Sarah Catherine Ogle | F459 | |
| Married | 18 Oct 1890 | , Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Child 6 | Female > Martha McCarter |
| Born | 3 May 1875 | , Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 24 Jan 1927 | |
| Buried | , Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Spouse | David "Dave" Ownby | F543 | |
| Married | Abt 1892 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Child 7 | Female > Isabella McCarter |
| Born | 30 Oct 1877 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 9 Aug 1963 | |
| Buried | Webbs Creek Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Spouse | Jesse Holloway Ramsey | F545 | |
| Married | 14 Feb 1895 | |
| Spouse | Rev. James Preston Lindsey | F12809 | |
| Married | ||
| Child 8 | Male > Eli McCarter, Jr. |
| Born | Feb 1880 | , Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 1928 | |
| Buried | , Monroe, Tennessee |
|
| Spouse | Melvina "Nelle" Carr | F546 | |
| Married | 15 Feb 1901 | , Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Child 9 | Male > Rev. Leander E. McCarter |
| Born | 6 Jul 1883 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 30 Oct 1963 | |
| Buried | Proffitt Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Spouse | Rhoda Anner Cole | F547 | |
| Married | 20 Jun 1899 | Sevier County, Tennessee |