| Father | Male Horatio B. Butler |
| Born | 29 Oct 1797 | Fairfax, Virginia  |
| Died | 20 Dec 1849 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Buried | Middle Creek Methodist Church Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Married | 21 Feb 1822 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Father | Henry Butler | F21559 Group Sheet | |
| Mother | ||
| Mother | Female Mary Jane Trotter |
| Born | 24 Jul 1804 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 7 Jul 1858 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Buried | Middle Creek Methodist Church Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Father | John Trotter | F10964 Group Sheet | |
| Mother | Asa White | F10964 Group Sheet | |
| Child 1 | Female > Nancy Butler |
| Born | 17 Dec 1822 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 16 Oct 1889 | |
| Buried | Middle Creek Methodist Church Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Spouse | Isaac Ogle, Jr. | F389 | |
| Married | Abt 1840/1841 | , Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Child 2 | Female > Anna Butler |
| Born | 22 Jul 1824 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | ||
| Buried | ||
| Spouse | Marion C. Clabough | F6705 | |
| Married | Abt 1855 | |
| Child 3 | Male > Henry Butler, Jr. |
| Born | 1 Sep 1826 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 13 Nov 1916 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Buried | Red Bank Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Spouse | Martha Reagan Emert | F1634 | |
| Married | Abt 1846 | , Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Child 4 | Male > John Butler |
| Born | 20 Mar 1828 | Tennessee |
| Died | 18 Sep 1913 | |
| Buried | Middle Creek Methodist Church Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Spouse | Martha Jane Flynn | F135516 | |
| Married | ||
| Spouse | Emeline Bogart | F18300 | |
| Married | 1 Apr 1858 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Child 5 | Female > Asa Butler |
| Born | 24 Nov 1832 | Tennessee |
| Died | 6 Sep 1910 | |
| Buried | Catons Chapel Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Spouse | James D. Emert | F14273 | |
| Married | Abt 1852 | , Sevier County, Tennessee |
 Child 7 | Male> McCajah Butler |
| Born | Abt 1836 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 10 Mar 1863 | |
| Buried | Stones River National Cemetery, Tennessee |
|
| Spouse | Mary McMahan | F120622 | |
| Married | ||
| Child 8 | Female > Mary Butler |
| Born | 7 Jul 1839 | Tennessee |
| Died | 3 Mar 1908 | |
| Buried | Pigeon Forge Methodist Church Cemetery, Pigeon Forge, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Spouse | Caleb Robertson | F21367 | |
| Married | ||
| Child 9 | Female > Jemima Butler |
| Born | 28 Feb 1842 | Sevier County, Tennessee |
| Died | 12 Dec 1920 | |
| Buried | Catons Chapel Cemetery, Sevier County, Tennessee |
|
| Spouse | Redmon C. F. McMahan | F13958 | |
| Married | 1 Oct 1862 | Sevier County, Tennessee |