| b 06 Mar 1921, , Cleveland, Oklahoma | William C. Valentine | > | Aaron H. Valentine | Mary Ann Shamblin | > |
| Marion Allen Valentine | b 20 Nov 1847 | James Jackson Proffitt | > | |
| | b 17 Jul 1873 | Elizabeth 'Betsy' Proffitt | Celia McMahan | > | |
| Walter Lee Valentine | d 02 Sep 1941 | b 11 Sep 1854 | ||
| |b 26 May 1898 | | | William M. Rollins | ||
| |d 1987 | Catherine Rachel L. Rollins | b 1847 | Benjamin R. Davis, [Rev.] | |
| | | b 22 Nov 1883 | Bertha Jane Davis | Ruth Ann Hipp | |
| Arlesa Catherine Valentine | d 26 Jun 1915 | b 1854 | ||
| |J. D. Tarver | | | John Oliver Kennedy | ||
| | | | | |||
| Ollie Clara Kennedy | ||||
| b 17 Oct 1903 | | | |||
| d 1970 | Arlesa | |||
Source: Rosa Lee Downey notes, 16 June 1983, p 97.