| Benajah Proffitt | > | James Jackson Proffitt | Sarah Byrd | |
| James McMahan 'Jim' Proffitt | b 28 Jun 1819 | James Balford 'Jim_Bally' McMahan | > | |
| | b 11 Mar 1844 | Celia McMahan | Mary Ann 'Polly' Wilson, 'Granny Mack' | > | |
| James Pentland 'Jim' Proffitt | d 11 Feb 1913 | b 07 Mar 1827 | Middleton Whaley | > |
| |b 20 Dec 1886 | | | Aaron Whaley | Rebecca Ogle | > |
| |d 26 Sep 1950 | Martha Whaley | b 02 Jan 1823 | John Ownby | > |
| | | b 25 Sep 1843 | Sarah Elmira 'Sally' Ownby | Mary Jane 'Granny' Coone | > |
| Donald Proffitt | d 27 Dec 1912 | b 1822 | William Clabaugh | > |
| |Alice | William Clabough, Jr. | Lavina King | > | | | Henry Clabough | b 1820 |
| | | |b 28 Nov 1852 | Elizabeth Handley | ||
| Lucinda Kate Clabough | d 21 Feb 1930 | b 1824 | Hercules 'Hike' Ogle | > |
| b 1894 | | | William H. 'Buck' Ogle | Elizabeth | |
| Lucinda Ogle | b 1804 | John Ownby | ||
| b 16 Jul 1852 | Rachel Ownby | Mary Jane 'Granny' Coone | > | |
| d 07 Feb 1925 | b 1818 | |||
Source: Rosa Lee Downey notes, 16 June 1983, p 85.